Printed March 14, 2026 03:31AM
You understand the second: standing in a comfort retailer forty minutes earlier than a future, lights buzzing overhead, gazing neon packets with names that sound much less like meals and extra like tech startups. Or perhaps you’re virtually an hour right into a path run, ripping open your first gel packet. Someplace between the substitute raspberry taste and the sugar spike, a small, inconvenient thought surfaces: What’s these items really doing for me…and to me?
The reality is, sports activities gels, electrolyte-infused sports activities drinks, and protein bars are engineered to supply nutrients for better performance. They ship on that entrance. However they’re additionally categorized as ultraprocessed foods or UPFs—items that are packed with preservatives, emulsifiers, colorings, and flavorings all within the effort to extend their shelf life, make them addictively scrumptious, and straightforward to digest. Regardless of these enticing traits, UPFs have been linked to most cancers, obesity, heart problems, despair, and even low muscle mass.
I’ve consumed sufficient gels and protein powder to fill a small landfill. I’m kidding (I feel). My grandmother definitely wouldn’t have known as them meals. Some days, I’m undecided I do both.
Elite athletes have fueled on these items for many years. So, what’s the true trade-off?
The Panic Over Ultraprocessed Meals Feels Modern—However It Isn’t
The time period “ultraprocessed meals” gained traction in the 1980s. Nonetheless, the opposition for them got here earlier. Within the seventies, well being critics had been already elevating alarms however had been typically dismissed as “meals faddists” or “pseudoscientists.”
Synthetic flavors and chemical components entered the American weight loss program within the nineteenth century, when saccharin (a zero-calorie sugar substitute like Candy N’ Low) and the ever-popular bubbly Coca-Cola confirmed up.
Hydrogenated oils stepped onto the scene in 1901. They had been injected into meals to make them last more, however the hydrogenation course of creates trans fats, the sort of fats that increases “bad” cholesterol.
After World Battle II, meals engineering accelerated because the army wanted giant portions of meals that may very well be transported and stay contemporary when shipped.
By the sixties, processed meals wasn’t a compromise. It was progress. In 1965, College of Florida doctor Dr. Robert Cade developed a drink to interchange the electrolytes soccer gamers misplaced by sweat. Inside a number of years, Gatorade was in all places. By the late nineties, engineered sports activities gasoline was mainstream.
How We Categorize Processed Meals
In 2009, Brazilian epidemiologist Carlos Monteiro launched the NOVA classification system, grouping meals by diploma of processing. These four categories are: no processing/minimal (fruits and veggies), processed elements like sugar or butter, processed meals similar to cheese or canned items, and ultraprocessed. His argument challenged nutrient-only pondering, as a substitute suggesting that how our meals is made might matter simply as a lot as what’s in it.
Some researchers have identified that NOVA paints with a fairly extensive brush. Cheerios, for example, technically qualify as ultra-processed underneath the system, regardless of being comprised of entire grain oats and containing comparatively little added sugar. It’s clear that not all ultraprocessed meals trigger the identical harm, so the system may have extra nuance.
However for athletes, the query of what issues extra turns into a sensible one: Does the processing matter, or what the processed meals replaces?
Elite Athletes Depend on Entire Meals and Some Ultraprocessed Merchandise
To search out out what elite athletes actually used to gasoline themselves, I reached out to Siri Lindley, a 2X World Champion Triathlete who was named the top triathlete in the world in 2001. However her each day weight loss program regarded nothing like what the trade was promoting.
At her peak, whereas dwelling in Switzerland, she ate contemporary meats, greens, dairy, entire breads—meals with out labels. “In Switzerland, meals tradition could be very totally different,” she tells me. “Little or no processed meals. That’s how I lived, and that’s once I was acting at my very best.”
On Olympic-distance race days—roughly two hours of high-intensity motion—she used one gel and a diluted electrolyte combine. Throughout coaching, she leaned on bananas and peanut butter sandwiches. Processed bars appeared solely often. Nonetheless, Lindley says that sponsorships typically affect athletes’ use of sports activities vitamin meals. “If an organization sponsored you, you used their merchandise. Magazines promoted them. It grew to become normalized,” she says. However gels and electrolyte mixes weren’t the rationale she grew to become a world champ. “The explanation I carried out at my finest was as a result of my each day life was constructed on actual meals, constant coaching, recovery, and emotional well-being.”
After surviving cancer, Lindley’s perspective sharpened. “Efficiency and well being aren’t separate techniques,” she says. “They’re deeply linked.”
As a triathlon coach, she now teaches athletes to assume in two layers: construct the muse with entire meals and use sports activities merchandise as instruments when the workload calls for it. For example, for Ironman athletes coaching 4 to 6 hours at a time, she acknowledges that speedy supply of carbs typically turns into essential. Nonetheless, for many leisure athletes, it isn’t, says Dr. Christine Fray, an affiliate professor of dietetics and vitamin on the College of Expertise in Jamaica.
How Dangerous Are Ultraprocessed Sports activities Meals, and Do They Have a Place in Our Diets?
Fray has labored extensively with elite athletes—together with Group Jamaica—and her analysis focuses on the intersection of weight problems, continual illnesses, and sports activities vitamin. She agrees that sports activities gels and drinks are technically UPFs.
Fray conveyed that among the many normal public, ultraprocessed meals typically displace whole foods and dominate each day consumption. For athletes, sports activities merchandise are designed to help extended effort, not exchange meals. A weight loss program excessive in UPFs has additionally been related to gut inflammation and fewer water consumption.
“The majority of the weight loss program ought to encompass wholesome, entire meals,” Fray says. She says that period is the important thing variable. “Sports activities vitamin merchandise could be helpful for endurance sports activities like marathons and Ironman occasions. They aren’t essential for sports activities of shorter period.”
However for actions that contain roughly 90 minutes of steady effort, in keeping with Fray, speedy carbohydrate and electrolyte supply may help delay fatigue. Under that 90-minute mark, Fray says most leisure runners can save their cash as a substitute of shopping for sports drinks or gels. “A standard weight loss program, together with coaching and proper hydration with water, will go a great distance.”
Can peak efficiency and long-term well being coexist? Fray is direct: They can. “A number of of our Jamaican athletes have carried out for years past the same old age 30 retirement age and have carried out effectively,” she says. “Our athletes use entire meals for probably the most half.”
The message is evident: Whole foods are the foundation, and sports activities merchandise generally is a useful software underneath particular circumstances.
Take into account This Earlier than Shopping for Your Subsequent Vitality Gel or Electrolyte Combine
The place does that depart the remainder of us—not world champions or Olympians—who wish to transfer effectively and never wreck ourselves within the course of? The reply could also be proportion. As Monteiro argued and as Lindley’s profession illustrates, what issues isn’t simply what’s in your meals. It’s what’s been carried out to it, and what it replaces.
Processed gasoline has a job. Lengthy races, sustained excessive depth, and prolonged classes are moments when speedy nutrient supply makes physiological sense. However these moments are rare for many of us.
Comfort shouldn’t exchange the dietary complexity of entire meals, similar to fiber and micronutrients that construct resilience, help restoration, and contribute to long-term well being. The query isn’t whether or not to remove ultraprocessed meals totally. It’s how a lot house they need to occupy in your each day life.
Perhaps the following time you’re standing in that comfort retailer gazing puffy packets, the query isn’t merely what to purchase. It’s whether or not it is advisable purchase something in any respect.
Need extra Outdoors well being tales? Sign up for the Bodywork newsletter. Should you’re able to turn into a runner, be part of The Weekly 45 Challenge on MapMy. The objective is to log 45 minutes of working or run-walking every week in March. That’s it. Plus, you may earn badges alongside the way in which and even win some cool prizes.
